Sheriff: Arrests made in ‘massacre’ of 3 fishing buddies in Polk County

Author: The Associated Press
Published: Updated:
L to R: Tony “TJ” Wiggins, William “Robert” Wiggins, Mary Whittemore (Credit: PCSO booking photos)

Two brothers and a woman have been arrested in connection with the “massacre” of three best friends who set out on a fishing trip at a Central Florida lake last week, Polk County Sheriff Grady Judd said Wednesday.

One of the suspects, Tony “TJ” Wiggins, 26, had previously been charged with 230 felonies, and had been consistently arrested since he was 12, Judd said during a news conference to announce the arrests. His brother William Robert Wiggins, 21, and girlfriend Mary Whittemore, 27, were also arrested.

The suspects are accused in the shooting and beating deaths of Damion Tillman, 23; Keven Springfield, 30; and Brandon Rollins, 27, on Friday night, as they gathered at a remote boat ramp at Lake Streety near Frostproof.

Judd, who has worked at the agency since 1972 called the crime scene “horrific,” describing the deaths as a “massacre.” He said the men were beaten and “shot up.”

“I’ve been to a lot of murder scenes in my life, and this ranks among the worst,” Judd said during a Saturday news conference.

According to the sheriff, Tillman was at a Dollar General store in the area and mentioned he was meeting his friends to go fishing at the lake. The store clerk later told investigators the suspects were in the store and overheard Tillman saying he was meeting up with his friends.

Judd said Tony Wiggins told his brother to drive to the lake. Once there, Tony Wiggins confronted Springfield, accusing him of stealing his truck and selling the engine. Judd said investigators have not yet determined whether that allegation is true.

The brother told detectives Tony Wiggins shot all three victims, then asked him to help put Tillman in the back of a truck.

The sheriff said the trio then went to a McDonald’s and ordered 10 double cheeseburgers and two chicken sandwiches.

Rollins was still alive when the attackers left, Judd said. He called his father for help. The father arrived about 10 minutes later but forgot his cellphone in a rush to help his son, so he went to a convenience store to get help.

By the time help arrived, his son had died.

Detectives received tips about the case and obtained video from the store. During a search warrant at the suspects’ homes, investigators found a gun that killed the victims, Judd said.

Tony Wiggins is charged with first-degree murder, tampering with evidence and possession of a firearm by a convicted felon. His brother and girlfriend are each charged with accessory after the fact. All three were expected to appear before a judge Thursday afternoon. Attorneys for them were not listed on court records.

Earlier, Judd had announced a reward of $30,000 leading to arrests in the case.

Copyright ©2024 Fort Myers Broadcasting. All rights reserved.

This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without prior written consent.