Bailey’s General Store on Sanibel auctioning wine that survived Ian to help fund rebuild

Reporter: Claire Galt Writer: Matthew Seaver
Published: Updated:

Bailey’s General Store has been in Sanibel for more than 100 years. Now they need a hand to rebuild, and what’s a better way to do that than wine and food?

Friends of Bailey’s are hosting the inaugural Waterline Wine Auction that will go to the rebuilding fund for the store.

Why is the wine being sold so special? It survived Hurricane Ian. A total of 3,200 bottles survived, and Bailey’s is auctioning them Sunday to raise cash to rebuild the store.

The owner also plans to donate some of the money to local non-profits.

Richard Johnson didn’t know he’d be the heir to Bailey’s legacy; it just happened that way. “Since I’m the son-in-law, it definitely was a calling,” said Johnson. “The Bailey family moved here in 1895”

They opened Bailey’s General Store in 1899. An astonishing record for a family-owned, mom-and-pop grocery store.

WINK News asked Johnson what their secret to success is. “It’s customer service. It’s that sense of community. It’s the place to go.”

It is the same reason they haven’t given up after being hit hard by Ian. “We need to be part; we need to be here for the community.”

Stepping into Bailey’s General Store today is like opening up a time capsule. Cans, cookies, Goldfish, and more are all perfectly placed on the shelves, just as they were on September 28.

Inside Bailey’s General Store after Ian. (Credit: WINK News)

The groceries somehow stayed in place as the building surrounding them experienced immense destruction.

“The wall of water took out our store and literally destroyed everything,” said Johnson.

Now, the lights are off, and the smell of mold and rotting food fills the air, but Johnson remembers it just as it was. “I remember faces. I remember friends and family and people that we had people that were in here every single day.”

“The kids would walk in, and the first thing when we see a group of kids walk in with their parents first thing we do is we get the parents and want to know if it’s OK for the kids to have a cookie. Every kid got a cookie when they want,” Johnson said.

The general store, and the businesses that surrounded it, are hard for Johnson to forget.

“Next door, another little small shop, Tips and Toes, was a manicurist that was here. Used to be the only barber shop on Sanibel for many years. Here’s an iconic spot here. Joey’s Custard. This is a family. All of these businesses are family-owned and operated.”

Seeing his store destroyed is hard, but a promise of the future makes that pain a little easier to deal with.

“I’m ready to close this chapter and work with our insurance carriers and get that wrapped up and move on with the rebuilding process,” said Johnson.

Bailey’s is going to cost between $15-20 million to rebuild. Johnson said their hope is to be up and running in 2024 or 2025 at the latest.

The auction to help support that rebuild will be held in the parking lot of Bailey’s General Store from 4 p.m. to 6 p.m. on Sunday.

(Credit: Bailey’s General Store)

Copyright ©2024 Fort Myers Broadcasting. All rights reserved.

This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without prior written consent.