Avoiding Moving Mistakes: One woman says she negotiated for weeks to get her stuff

Reporter: Sara Girard
Published: Updated:
Moving boxes. Credit: MGN

Moving can be emotional. But for one woman, the emotion didn’t come from leaving behind memories; it came from not knowing if she’d ever get her memories back.

Jill Ambrose told WINK News she waited more than two months to get her stuff from the movers all because of a fight over the final price.

“[You] move to a state that’s so beautiful and you end up like this,” Ambrose said. “It’s hard.”

Nowadays her house feels more like a home, but during her first nine weeks in Naples, it sat nearly empty. The furniture she did have was either borrowed from friends or family, or bought just to fill the space, so she’d have somewhere to sleep and sit down for dinner. She didn’t know what happened to her actual belongings.

“It’s heartbreaking,” she said. “The furniture you can replace. But the personal things, you just can’t.”

Ambrose says she called a few moving companies but ended up going with the one she thought offered the best deal. She agreed to pay a little more than $1,200 to move from New Jersey to Naples.

According to consumer attorney David Fineman, that should have been the first red flag.

“If something is too good to be true, it most likely is,” Fineman said.

Then there was the second red flag.

“I said do you want to come and see [my items], he [the man giving the estimate] said no we don’t need to do that,” said Ambrose. “I even offered to send pictures, [he said I] didn’t need them.”

But Fineman explains, not getting an exact inventory of what you want to be moved, either in person or by sending pictures, could cost you more money.

“Like anything else, the devil is in the details,” Fineman said. “If you don’t get your list of items that are going to be moved, then you can’t really hold anyone’s feet to the fire on your contract.”

And that’s exactly what happened. The day of the move, Ambrose admits she had a few more boxes than she originally was quoted for, but she was not prepared for what happened next. The contract jumped from just over $1,200 to $4,788. While the terms of her contract said additional items would mean a revised estimate, Ambrose was not prepared for such a big price hike.

“I said that can’t possibly be,” recalled Ambrose. “And he said well it is– and either you sign this contract or we’re taking it [your stuff] off [the truck] and putting it in your driveway.”

Under pressure, Ambrose says she signed the new agreement.

“When they were pulling out the driveway I didn’t think I was going to see my things anymore,” she said. “I just had a bad feeling about it.”

After weeks of negotiating, and with her life in limbo, she ended up agreeing to a new price of just over $4,200.

We spoke to the moving company and they told us Ambrose did have more items than she was originally quoted for, so they had to charge more.


  • Make sure you research any mover before hiring at freshfromflorida.com
  • Click here to check movers registered in Florida.
  • Click here for movers registered for interstate moves.

Copyright ©2024 Fort Myers Broadcasting. All rights reserved.

This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without prior written consent.