Most Wanted Wednesday: We feature three of SWFL’s most wanted suspects; May 20

Reporter: Rich Kolko
Published: Updated:
Sheldon Cadore

This weekly WINK News segment features fugitives from justice right here in Southwest Florida.

This is your chance to help out the community and give the tip that gets these people off the street. These suspects need to be found – and you can help. If you have seen them, reach out to Crime Stoppers or your local law enforcement. Call 1-800-780-TIPS (8477).

Here are three suspects wanted by Southwest Florida Crime Stoppers.

MORE: See all of our Most Wanted Wednesday suspects

Sheldon Cadore

Sheldon Cadore (DOB 8/18/78) – wanted in Lee County on a bench warrant for two counts of sexual battery on a child & lewd and lascivious molestation. This guy was accused of sexual battery on an 11-year-old victim.

He actually confessed in court to the crime and even took the stand at the beginning of his trial to defend himself, saying that he didn’t see anything wrong with what he did. However, when it came for the trial to wrap up, Cadore took off (he wasn’t being held in custody during the trial) and never returned.

Despite his absence, the judge still found Cadore guilty in his absence, sentencing him two life sentences for his crimes. Cadore had some pretty strong roots in the Hunters Park community in Lee County (near Pine Manor) but completely abandoned his last known residence.

He has connections in New York, but no matter where he has fled, we will happily extradite him back. He’s 5’8”, 145 pounds and of course will be held without bond.

Alex Mata Garcia

Alex Mata Garcia (DOB 6/2/99) – Mata Garcia has a bench warrant for failure to appear in court on charges of lewd or lascivious battery.

Police say this 20-year-old man was having sexual relations with a 12-year-old girl after the two met on social media.

When the girl told a trusted adult, police questioned Mata Garcia, who said that he thought the girl was 16 – which would have still made his actions illegal.

Mata Garcia spent one month in jail for this charge before posting $25,000 bail. He was supposed to show back up in court for a hearing in February, however, he’s been AWOL ever since.

He was last known to be working for a roofing company, under the alias of Franklin Morales Garcia. He is 4’11”, 140 pounds, and has a red birthmark on his temple. His last known address is in East Fort Myers.

Anthony Kats

[CAPTURED] Anthony Kats (DOB 2/26/87) – Kats is wanted in Lee County for violation of probation for robbery and possession of a controlled substance. His current warrant stems from an incident when he approached the victim, who was someone he knew from the shrimp docks on Fort Myers Beach.

Deputies say Kats went to grab the man’s wallet from his back pocket, but when the victim resisted, Kats launched a series of blows to the man’s face, ultimately getting away with the wallet and leaving the victim bloodied and bruised.

Since the victim was familiar with Kats, he was quickly arrested and spent three months in lock-up for the robbery and assault.

Last week he violated his probation, which triggered a new warrant for his arrest. He has five Lee County bookings and one in Hendry. He is 6’1”, 190 pounds, and was last known to be living in downtown Fort Myers. Upon his arrest, he’ll be held without bond.

Brayton Logan

[CAPTURED] Brayton Logan (DOB 7/15/91) – Logan has a bench warrant for failure to appear on charges of burglary and petit theft.

Logan worked for a local roofer and after work on a Friday afternoon, he went back to the job site and stole a long list of power tools.

Police say he then took the items to a Cape Coral pawn shop and sold them for pennies on the dollar. Logan has a history of theft that dates back to 2014.

He has five prior arrests in Lee County and one in Bay County. He is 5’7”, 155 pounds, and was last known to be living in North Cape Coral. He will also be held without bond upon his arrest.

MORE: See all of our Most Wanted Wednesday suspects

If you have a tip on the whereabouts of any of these wanted suspects contact Southwest Florida Crime Stoppers. All callers will remain anonymous and will be eligible for a cash reward of up to $3,000.

Southwest Florida Crime Stoppers
1-800-780-TIPS (8477) or

Crime Stoppers

Copyright ©2023 Fort Myers Broadcasting. All rights reserved.

This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without prior written consent.